LIAR Grid for Newspapers

Use this grid and adopt your notes depending on the edition you are revising from. Keep adding to it as you learn more facts .

L                                                                                                                                                   Media Language

I                                                                                                                                               Industry
Genre conventions: Changed to tabloid size in 200 but retains many genre conventions of its original broadsheet form:
Masthead- blue with white font- recently changed from sans serif to a serif, slightly more ornate font, perhaps to connote/signify more serious or sophisticated brand
Headline- paraphrases Trump’s denial of criticising the British PM; the recently coined phrase “fake news” is synonymous with Trump and creates slightly mocking representation of the US president. See industry.
Splash and copy- words with negative connotations used to describe Trump as “rambling and occasionally surreal” in an “extraordinary press conference” covering a “dizzying range” of topics. The discourse implies incompetence and focuses on Trump’s unconventional presentation style that he is often ridiculed for.
Images- Large, central, slightly comical image that represents Trump as bullish and domineering through gesture codes, confidently striding whilst holding the British PM firmly by the arm. The US and UK flags connote patriotism and act as a reminder of the special relationship the countries have historically.

Supplements-  Positive lexis “incredible journey”, “award-winning”; direct address “your” with attractive images to promote them.

Steve Neale- genre is a process by which genre codes and conventions are shared by producers and audiences through repetition in media products.

Roland Barthes- semiology is the study of signs. Signs have denotations and connotations. These can create ‘myths’.
This is when ideological meanings are formed by repetition. E.g. Trump’s rise to power, as a populist ‘anti-establishment’ businessman turned politician is a myth he himself promotes. His hair is a ‘signifier’ of this and a “magical object” that people come to associate with his mythology.

                                                                 
Ownership:
Funded by Scott Trust, existing solely to support the production of the Guardian and purports to uphold journalistic freedom and liberal values
Advertisers include car manufacturers, wine clubs, electrical stores, supermarkets (co-op), tech brands which generate revenue for the Guardian newspaper.
Regulation:
UK has free press.
Self-regulated rather than IPSO. Administered by an independent readers’ editor with an appeals panel back-up.

Distribution/circulation:
Print sales in decline due to technology and availability of free online news. Offers a subscription service to encourage regular customers, which rewards with reduced price. Also offers home delivery service within M25. See Audience. Still considered more trustworthy as a source than online outlets and most print newspapers (e.g. compared to Daily Mail, audience trust scores are high) with high standards of fact-checking and impartiality which would not be possible online due to the expectation of fast news by audiences.



Curran and Seaton- Power and Media Industries
The Guardian is unique in that it is not owned by a conglomerate. C &S looked at how capitalism creates a pattern of increasing concentration of ownership into fewer hands which narrows the range of opinions and puts profit ahead of creativity or quality.

Hesmondhalgh- Cultural Industries
Cultural production owned and controlled by a few conglomerates- not in the case of the Guardian.

Livingstone and Lunt- Regulation
Looked at how technology (digital media, media convergence, globalised media industries) has made traditional regulation (like Ofcom/IPSO) more difficult.

A                                                                                                                                                   Audience
R                                                                                                                                              Representation

Demographics: lower % of over 65s (DM has highest), 28% are Millenials (under 35s) , with an even gender split. 86% are ABC1 and 65% educated to degree level or higher.

Psychographics: Guardian say- progressive, active fashion and tech consumers, well-travelled, finance savvy, affluent and well educated, passion for food, art and culture.

Political affiliations: Left wing. Tend to be Labour or Liberal Democrat voters. Therefore discourse tends to favour more liberal, progressive narrative. This is reflected in the representation of Trump. It may also cultivate that opinion in its readers
                                                      
Stuart Hall- reception theory
Text producers encode, audiences decode. Their responses are shaped by a range of social, cultural factors and may be preferred, negotiated or oppositional. A preferred reading of the splash and main image would be one that sees Trump as lacking finesse and ability as a politician.

Clay Shirkey- End of Audience
Print newspapers use the old model of ‘filter then publish’, hence more reliable than online. See Industry.
Trump is represented as confident, bullish and somewhat incompetent. See Media Language.
The image depicts him as in control, front and centre compositionally; head raised to the cameras, whilst May faces the floor, his hand on her arm (as if she is being escorted somewhere). His raised hand connotes a playfulness but when anchored by the headline about fake news, is also conspiratorial, which further reinforces ideas about Trump’s unconventional relationship with the media.

Men are represented in two ways in the splash and the teaser for the World Cup souvenir. In the Trump story, we can see a traditional representation where the male politician appears to be in control and have political power. This is contradicted somewhat through the article’s undermining of Trump’s credibility. Nonetheless, he still remains the focus of the lead story about their meeting.
 The footballers display a range of emotions but the main one is Harry Kane, teeth bared in a show of passion or aggression. Overall, the images represent men in a traditional way: athletic and competitive, but it could be suggested that the image of Jordan Pickford crying offers a more modern representation.

Stuart Hall- representation is not about whether the media distorts or reflects reality because that suggests there is a ‘true’ meaning, when in fact many meanings can be generated in the audience.

Gauntlett- identity
Media helps audiences to shape their own ideas about identity. The media offers a diverse range of identities for us to consider, particularly new media.
Van Zoonen- Feminist theory
In patriarchal culture, women’s bodies represented as objects, mens’ as spectacle.